Was Wang Feng hacked by the media, or could he not afford to lose？

On September 10, the scuffle between Yu Chengqing and Wang Feng in the fourth season of "The Voice of China" (the ranking is only based on the order of the scene) began to be recorded. Near the early morning, rumors of "Wang Feng tearing the media" began to circulate on the Internet. This morning, the incident fermented again, and rumors of "clearing the scene and re-recording" were rampant. Tencent Entertainment tried its best to restore the event itself by recording the scene, the narratives of media people and musicians.

Question 1: Was the Feng Feng team destroyed?

Restore: 0:4 results are rumors

Considering that the program had not yet been broadcast, the details of the melee between Yu Chengqing and Wang Fengzu could not be revealed one by one, but the news that "the Fengzhao team was destroyed" was once widely spread on the Internet. The reporters who followed the recording throughout the process could state responsibly that "the destruction of the team" was false.

On the evening of the 10th, a blogger named "Lamp HOHO" took the lead in posting a Weibo, to the effect that during the melee, Wang Feng’s team lost 0:4. (This Weibo has now been deleted.) In fact, according to the competition system, the melee is a contest of 8 to 5, and the worst result, the instructor will definitely have a student enter the next round. And the actual recording situation is indeed not "group destruction".

Question 2: Did Wang Feng tear up the media?

Restoration: Emotional stability during expression

From last night to this morning, the most commonly used wording on Weibo about the melee between Yu Chengqing and Wang Feng was – Wang Feng "tore" the media. As the media present, it needs to be objectively stated that when Wang Feng asked the director team to allow him to express his position, although his expression was quite serious, it was definitely not "torn".

Wang Feng’s serious expression began after the results of the first round were released. At that time, he sent his capable generals, and the students of the Yu Chengqing group were equally strong. After the voting ended, the Yu Chengqing team took the lead by a narrow margin. Since the second round of voting, Wang Feng rarely turned his head to look at the voting process, and when the jury commented one after another, he kept looking into the distance. During this process, Wang Feng intermittently negotiated with the general director Jin Lei and the live director.

Wang Feng’s speech, which was widely rumored on the Internet, took place after the third round of voting. Before that, Na Ying, who was also a mentor, tried to comfort Wang Feng. Later, the director team also negotiated with Na Ying. The former couldn’t hear what he said because he didn’t have Dai Mai, but Na Ying said "I can’t hold him back" but it came out of the stereo.

The full text of Wang Feng’s speech is as follows:

So I want to say it again, there is no problem between me and Mr. Harlin. What I say next has nothing to do with Mr. Harlin or his students. XX (involving spoilers, students keep it a secret), and the two students who lost in front of us, I must tell you, I must say sorry to you.

Please forgive my bluntness, you didn’t lose in the music, you didn’t lose in the eyes of Mr. Harlem, and you didn’t lose in the wonderful singing of the other students. You lost in the worldly criticism and prejudice, and those criticism and prejudice are against your instructors. Don’t cry, I would like to thank all the bands, directors, and our music producers, music critics, and DJs from The Voice. The instructors want to apologize to you, and the three in front of us. I believe your performance is almost perfect, because the truth cannot be changed. But I am especially sorry that it was because I hurt you.

In fact, there are some grievances and criticisms that I can bear, but I should not let these children bear. I thank you, all the students who performed just now (I do not recommend applauding now, thank you), and all the impressions you gave me just now, including the singing of all the members of Mr. Harlem’s team, I think it is a particularly great experience and wealth in my life.

After I said these words, I was faced with another student in our team, but I didn’t care anymore. I said a sentence a long time ago, the result is possible at any time, and the result is unpredictable and at your mercy at any time, but your singing will definitely be broadcast. All the people on the scene, the memory will not be erased.

Question 3: Vote against Wang Feng?

Restore: The first three rows also have media

Weibo, which is also "Lamp HOHO", also broke the news that some media colleagues had revealed to him before the recording that they would join forces to destroy the Wang Feng team. The voting results at the scene showed that Yu Chengqing won 26:25 in 2 rounds, and the other 3 rounds, no matter who won or lost, the score difference was also very small.

During the break of the recording scene, some colleagues told reporters that they felt quite helpless. "I voted for the Wang Feng group in the first round," "This year’s Harlem group is indeed slightly better," "It is very difficult to win in such a row of troops, strong encounters," and after the third round of voting, some colleagues felt wronged: "I just finished voting for the Wang Feng group, and I was said to be’biased ‘."

When it was officially broadcast, netizens could carefully study and judge. Almost none of the 51 judges voted for Yu Chengqing’s team in 5 rounds of voting, but there were many who voted for Wang Feng. Each of the 51 judges had 20 seconds to give the reasons for their choice. If there was a complete broadcast version, netizens could wait for the broadcast before giving their own answers.

Some netizens also questioned: the voting gap between the first three rows is very small, because it is professionals; the last two rows are dominated by the media, which is easy to reverse the situation. First of all, the reporters represented Tencent Video and sat in the first row, and the first three rows were not all musicians and music critics. Secondly, when voting on the spot, there were not many media in the last two rows who voted for Wang Feng.

Question 4: Does the media use "secular" to counter-choke?

Restore: Music is inherently incomparable

It was still circulating on the Internet that the reporter at the scene satirized Wang Feng for no reason: "I am worldly." Clarifying the order first, after Wang Feng’s declaration of "worldly prejudice" was finished, the media responded to the word "worldly" at the scene. There were more than one, but it was taken out of context. One of the media representatives, after choosing the students of Wang Feng’s team, said: "I know very worldly that Mr. Harlin will definitely save XX."

Today, music critic Kohl Qinfu posted a Moments, writing: "After the recording of The Voice of China ended, I was touched by wind and rain, but I also regretted that the contestant I liked and the contestant I liked in terms of appearance and temperament were not able to stay. The latter didn’t vote for her because of her singing flaws, so I wasn’t happy…" Kohl Qinfu’s torn was the same as everyone in the jury present.

Later, Kolchenf added: "I fully understand that there are left and right in the crowd." As the on-site judges said, music is inherently subjective, so music cannot be compared. But on "The Voice", there is always a winner or loser.

Question 5: It’s not shady, why does Liu Zhuo support it?

Restoration: Wang Feng and Liu Zhuo arranged for the team together

"I just want to express my personal opinion, everyone will understand. I think Lao Wang is a special man today! Responsible! From the bottom of my heart, I have reacquainted with this worthy musician! In the matter of treating music, he is definitely worthy of everyone! It is really shameful for the so-called grudges to be placed on these lovely children by this group of people who have no bottom line. I hope the music that has been achieved through hard work can last longer…" This is Liu Zhuo’s Weibo released during the recording last night.

Why did Liu Zhuo support Wang Feng? Among them, he complained for Wang Feng and also for himself. In order to try his best to restore it, the reporter needs to state a fact, which is also what Wang Feng himself stated at the recording site: this time, Wang Feng and Liu Zhuo arranged many of the melee songs of Wang Feng’s team together, and even the symphony part was specially recorded by the two in Beijing.

Question 6: Is the audience clearing the scene for re-recording?

Restore: To be determined, students cannot watch the rehearsal

After something happened on the recording scene, there was a stir on the Internet again, and some people said with certainty: "Because Wang Feng went crazy, the scene was cleared and re-recorded." The scene was to be cleared, and the previous mentor assessment (Battle) and the championship battle (Live Show) in the mentor group were in the final stage, in order to keep the results confidential.

This year’s melee was rather special because there were still two places to be determined for another round of singing. The netizens who were slightly familiar with the recording of "The Voice" should know that before the new round of competition, the students would always be asked to rehearse again, and the rehearsal must be cleared before the rehearsal.

The so-called re-recording, the reporter has been following for 4 years since the first season of "The Voice", and has never seen a match that can be re-recorded. Last night’s recording scene, not only the program team, the jury, but also the students in the two mentor groups, all of them said that re-recording can be re-recorded?